The Clash of Sports Officials and Fans: When Free Speech Borders Harassment
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.18666/TPE-2024-V81-I3-11722Abstract
In the case of Higgins v. Kentucky Sports Radio LLC (2020), John Higgins was officiating an Elite Eight March Madness game in 2017 where the University of Kentucky (UK) was facing the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill (UNC). After UK lost the game, Kentucky fans were upset and blamed Higgins for the loss. Two of these fans included Matthew Jones and Drew Franklin, a host and writer for Kentucky Sports Radio. Following the loss, Jones and Franklin criticized Higgins and his personal roofing business through their radio station. His business was bombarded with calls, death threats, and negative reviews. Higgins sought damages in excess of $75,000 from Kentucky Sports Radio for inflicting harm through their commentary. The purpose of this law review is to examine the rights of sports officials and fans, summarize the case facts and court decision, and determine how the ruling impacts sports officials broadly.
Keywords: Sports Officials, Fans, Basketball, First Amendment, Tort
References
Aspen Institute. (2021). State of Play 2021 [Infographic]. Aspen Project Play. https://www.aspenprojectplay.org/state-of-play-2021/ages-6-12
Bible Believers v. Wayne County, 805 F.3d 228, 246 (2015).
Brintley v. Aeroquip Credit Union, 936 F.3d 489, 494 (2019).
Branch, J. (2019, March 20). The N.C.A.A. team that just can’t win. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/20/sports/ncaa-tournament-referees.html
Duvinage, C. (2012). Referees in sports contests: The economic role and the problem of corruption in professional german sports leagues. Gabler Verlag.
Facebook (2022, January 4). Terms of service. Retrieved April 24, 2022. https://www.facebook.com/terms.php
Forde, P. (2022, March 23). NCAA tournament showcasing lack of consistency and accountability in officiating. Sports Illustrated. https://www.si.com/college/2022/03/24/ncaa-tournament-referees-lacking-consistency-accountability
Hite, G. (2021, February 17). Film doesn’t lie: How to watch game film and get better as a referee. Georgia Lacrosse Officials Association. https://galaxref.com/film-doesnt-lie-you-do-how-to-watch-game-film-and-get-better-as-a-referee/
Hustler Magazine, Inc. v. Falwell, 485 U.S. 46, 50 (1988).
Jamieson, L. M. (2021, July 30). Abuse of officials: A sign of poor sports management? Center on Sport Policy and Conduct. https://www.sportpolicycenter.com/news/2021/7/30/abuse-of-officials-a-sign-of-poor-sports-management
Karp, A. (2022, January 1). Sports’ TV dominance at new heights in 2021. Sports Business Journal. https://www.sportsbusinessjournal.com/Journal/Issues/2022/01/10/Upfront/Ratings.aspx
Mayer v. Belichick, 605 F.3d 223, 237 (2010).
National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA). (2020). NCAA recruiting facts. https://ncaaorg.s3.amazonaws.com/compliance/recruiting/NCAA_RecruitingFactSheet.pdf
Niehoff, K. (2021, April 28). More officials, better fan behavior needed in high school sports. National Federation of State High School Associations. https://nfhs.org/articles/more-officials-better-fan-behavior-needed-in-high-school-sports/
Parrot, T.V. (2021, April 5). Profit motives make fixing college sports nearly impossible. Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2021/04/05/profit-motives-make-fixing-college-sports-nearly-impossible/
San Diego v. Roe, 543 U.S. 77, 83-84 (2004).
Time, Inc. v. Johnston, 448 F.2d 378, 383 (1971).
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2022, April 21). Umpires, referees, and other sports officials. https://www.bls.gov/ooh/entertainment-and-sports/umpires-referees-and-other-sports-officials.htm
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Sagamore Publishing LLC (hereinafter the “Copyright Owner”)
Journal Publishing Copyright Agreement for Authors
PLEASE REVIEW OUR POLICIES AND THE PUBLISHING AGREEMENT, AND INDICATE YOUR ACCEPTANCE OF THE TERMS BY CHECKING THE ‘AGREE TO THE TERMS OF THIS COPYRIGHT NOTICE’ CHECKBOX BELOW.
I understand that by submitting an article to The Physical Educator, I am granting the copyright to the article submitted for consideration for publication in The Physical Educator to the Copyright Owner. If after consideration of the Editor of the The Physical Educator, the article is not accepted for publication, all copyright covered under this agreement will be automatically returned to the Author(s).
THE PUBLISHING AGREEMENT
Assignment of Copyright
I hereby assign to the Copyright Owner the copyright in the manuscript I am submitting in this online procedure and any tables, illustrations or other material submitted for publication as part of the manuscript in all forms and media (whether now known or later developed), throughout the world, in all languages, for the full term of copyright, effective when the article is accepted for publication.
Reversion of Rights
Articles may sometimes be accepted for publication but later be rejected in the publication process, even in some cases after public posting in “Articles in Press” form, in which case all rights will revert to the Author.
Retention of Rights for Scholarly Purposes
I understand that I retain or am hereby granted the Retained Rights. The Retained Rights include the right to use the Preprint, Accepted Manuscript, and the Published Journal Article for Personal Use and Internal Institutional Use.
All journal material is under a 12 month embargo. Authors who would like to have their articles available as open access should contact Sagamore-Venture for further information.
In the case of the Accepted Manuscript and the Published Journal Article, the Retained Rights exclude Commercial Use, other than use by the author in a subsequent compilation of the author’s works or to extend the Article to book length form or re-use by the author of portions or excerpts in other works.
Published Journal Article: the author may share a link to the formal publication through the relevant DOI.
Author Representations
- The Article I have submitted to the journal for review is original, has been written by the stated author(s) and has not been published elsewhere.
- The Article was not submitted for review to another journal while under review by this journal and will not be submitted to any other journal.
- The Article contains no libelous or other unlawful statements and does not contain any materials that violate any personal or proprietary rights of any other person or entity.
- I have obtained written permission from copyright owners for any excerpts from copyrighted works that are included and have credited the sources in the Article.
- If the Article was prepared jointly with other authors, I have informed the co-author(s) of the terms of this Journal Publishing Agreement and that I am signing on their behalf as their agent, and I am authorized to do so.