The Effect of Music- and Video-Distraction on High School Physical Education Student Exercise Intensity

Authors

  • Kelsey Higginson The Ohio State University
  • David Barney Brigham Young University
  • Keven Prusak Brigham Young University
  • Carol Wilkinson Brigham Young University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.18666/TPE-2019-V76-I4-8903

Keywords:

music, movies, adolescents, exercise

Abstract

This study investigated the relationship between use of distractions during exercise and (a) heart rate (HR), (b) rating of perceived exertion (RPE), and (c) enjoyment during exercise. Quasi-experimental design with six intact, single-gender high school classes was used. A control group experienced no distraction, while a treatment group first experienced no distraction, followed by 2 days each of listening to music and of watching a movie. HR was collected continuously in real time and RPE and enjoyment at 5-min intervals. In the treatment group, HR and RPE were not different between no distraction and music conditions but decreased while watching a film. The control group also decreased in the same measures during the third condition. No differences were seen in enjoyment. While various distractions may work in fitness settings, in the PE setting distractions in and of themselves are insufficient and cannot replace quality pedagogy and an engaging teacher. One cannot simply turn on the music or video and leave students to their own devices. Future research needs to investigate distraction use in combination with good pedagogy, engaging instruction, and the impact of sociality in physical education.Subscribe to TPE

Author Biographies

Kelsey Higginson, The Ohio State University

Graduate Student

David Barney, Brigham Young University

Associate Professor

Keven Prusak, Brigham Young University

Associate Professor

Carol Wilkinson, Brigham Young University

Associate Professor

Published

2019-10-15

Issue

Section

Articles